expectations
Position Paper Grading Rubric
5 dimensions × 5 points = 25 total. Includes CSV submission format and Best Position Paper criteria.
# Position Paper Grading Rubric · KnightMUN 2026
Score each paper 0-25 across 5 dimensions (5 each). Top 6 per committee shortlist for **Best Position Paper**. Total fed into the conference-day rubric (weights to 30%).
## Dimensions
### 1. Country accuracy (5 pts)
- 5 — Reflects actual current government position. Cites specific recent statements, votes, or treaty positions.
- 3 — Reflects general country posture. Some citation but vague.
- 1 — Reads like the delegate's personal views, not the country's.
- 0 — Wrong country position (e.g., neutral language for an active belligerent).
### 2. Evidence (5 pts)
- 5 — 3+ citations to UN documents, real treaties, or peer-reviewed sources.
- 3 — 1-2 citations.
- 1 — Wikipedia-tier sources only.
- 0 — No citations.
### 3. Specificity of proposals (5 pts)
- 5 — Names specific clauses, mechanisms, dollar amounts, dates.
- 3 — General direction with some specifics.
- 1 — Vague aspirations ("strengthen international cooperation").
- 0 — No proposals.
### 4. Writing quality (5 pts)
- 5 — Clear, concise, well-structured, no typos.
- 3 — Mostly clear with minor issues.
- 1 — Hard to follow.
- 0 — Incomprehensible.
### 5. Format compliance (5 pts)
- 5 — 1.5 pages max, 12pt Times, 1" margins, header complete.
- 3 — Minor format issues (e.g., wrong font, missing one header element).
- 1 — Major format issues.
- 0 — Doesn't meet basic format.
## Submitting your scores
By **October 14** (4 days after the deadline), submit a `.csv` or paste your scores into the chair portal:
```
country,total,substance,evidence,specificity,writing,format,notes
"United States",22,5,5,4,5,3,"Strong CCW GGE citations; format minor (used Calibri)"
```
## Best Position Paper award
Top score per committee. Tie-broken by chair's qualitative preference.